Skip to content


Despair

76 comments


“I… I just can’t,” he sobs into his hands. “I can’t take care of myself… I can’t deal with things. I need to be in a home.”

“Any family? Anyone you could stay with?” I ask, already knowing the answer. Still, I hope that somewhere in his fractured memories, a loving family member might magically appear, someone who will take him in. I hope, and always I am disappointed.

“None,” he sighs raggedly, twisting a dirty sock in his hands. “There’s nobody but me.”

We sit on the side of a bare mattress in a seedy hotel room, surrounded by half-eaten food and piles of clothes, the room reeking of unwashed body and stale cigarettes. I wouldn’t be surprised if he hadn’t left this room since I’d seen him last.

“I need to be in a home,” he repeats, breaking into a fresh round of sobs. “Why won’t they put me in a home?”

I know why, but I offer no answer. How horrible must his demons be, that living in an institution would be his greatest hope? I vacillate between thanking God I will never know what he is going through, and wishing I did, and thus somehow understand him better and perhaps hate him less.

And God help me, hate him I do, sometimes. Every time the call comes in, “Non-life-threatening emergency, no priority symptoms. 50-year-old male, states he can’t take care of himself,” I know it will be him, and the weariness grips me and threatens to drain whatever small satisfaction I gain from doing what I do.

This wasn’t what I signed on for. This isn’t what I’m trained for. There is nothing wrong with his body; no illness to treat, no wounds to bind. It’s his mind that is broken, and there is nothing that I, or all the psychiatrists in the world, or anyone short of God himself can do to repair it.

And the futility of it makes me resent him terribly, makes me dread seeing his face. And the shame that he might see the resentment on mine burns me like a torch.

And so I say nothing, sitting silently beside him, and I bear witness to his despair.

“Why won’t they take me?” he sobs plaintively, clutching desperately at my arm. “Call Zeke,” he begs. “Zeke’s my friend. He’ll make them put me in. I can’t survive out here.

How bleak must his life be, that he regards the parish coroner as his savior? People only interact with a coroner when a relative has died, or when someone thinks they’re crazy. Neither is a happy occasion.

The truth is that he’s not sick enough to be locked away. He doesn’t hallucinate, doesn’t hear voices urging him to do bad things. He doesn’t contemplate killing himself. He calls for the same reason he did last week, and last month, and a dozen times before that. He is simply a man for whom living independently and wrestling his demons are two tasks he will never, ever be able to manage simultaneously.

And he knows it.

He is too honest to game the system, too naive to understand that’s what it may take. Should I tell him what to say, how to act so that he’ll get at least a few days in a place of comfort, where people may at least pretend to care about his welfare? I certainly know the litany well enough. I could teach him the magic words.

But then, how will I justify it to myself, knowing that he’ll be taking up bed space needed by someone who is truly a danger to himself or others? In post-Katrina Louisiana, psych beds are all too precious a commodity. Mentally ill patients here move through a vicious cycle of hospitalization, medication, discharge, decompensation, hospitalization, medication, discharge…

… fragile people stuck in a meaningless revolving door of all too many psychotropic medications and all too little meaningful therapy, and altogether nonexistent followup care. They warehouse them and dope them with Haldol and Thorazine until their reimbursement capitates, and then suddenly declare that they’ve made significant progress and are ready to be released again into the world, with a prescription for medications everyone knows they can’t afford and outpatient appointments with a psychiatrist everyone knows they won’t be able to keep.

And if I did coach him on how to get committed, it would be a temporary solution at best. He’d likely spend at least 24 hours in the ER awaiting a psych bed… somewhere. And the ER nurses hate to see him coming, their weariness and distaste manifest in their expressions. It’s an expression I know well. I’ve worn it myself.

And so I don’t coach him on how to act, don’t tell him what to say. Resignation and dismay radiate from him like a roiling black cloud, threatening to envelop me if I get too close.

So instead I sit there, silently at his bedside, and I bear witness to his despair.

I find myself wondering what is the point of it all, asking myself if something, anything I do makes a difference. Patients like him certainly make me doubt.

Rookie Partner putters around the room, gathering medications, clothing, and personal effects. Wallet and a half-empty pack of Newports, keys and a small laminated card with the 23rd Psalm written upon it; they all go into a bag with the cleanest clothing and underwear we can find. A search is launched for his cigarette lighter, and RP’s impatience is etched upon his face as I make him scour the room for it.

The unspoken message is that finding the lighter itself isn’t so important as showing him that someone cares enough to look for it. RP may not get that yet, but he will. We’re still working on our nonverbal communication.

Finally the lighter is found, and it goes in the bag too, tucked carefully between the cigarette pack and its cellophane wrapper. RP waits by the door, patiently now, as our patient sits on the bed, still anxiously twisting that sock in his hands.

“Do you think they’ll admit me?” he asks tearfully, afraid to hope.

“I don’t know,” I dodge, and he sees the answer for what it is. He starts to cry again.

And silently I sit beside him, and I bear witness to his despair.

And then the radio crackles, and the pager vibrates, reminding me that we’ve lingered here too long.

“Come on Roger, it’s time to go,” I tell him gently, taking his hand and placing another on his shoulder. “Don’t worry, man. We’ll take care of you.”

  • Lee

    What's really depressing is that in states where beds are more plentiful (Eg: NY) the same cycle exists across the board. The cycle doesn't seem to be dependent on the number of beds or the amount of money in the system. I like to think it's the people in the system that are burnt out and/or beaten down, but fear it's just normal human reaction to the people who are afflicted.

  • Lee

    What's really depressing is that in states where beds are more plentiful (Eg: NY) the same cycle exists across the board.

    The cycle doesn't seem to be dependent on the number of beds or the amount of money in the system. I like to think it's the people in the system that are burnt out and/or beaten down, but fear it's just normal human reaction to the people who are afflicted.

  • Lissa

    Oh, AD.My soul hurts for yours, and his.

  • Lissa

    Oh, AD.
    My soul hurts for yours, and his.

  • Anonymous

    I'd say that at some point this guy is going to start finding the situation is more that he can handle even "well" as he is now and might turn to suicide. The rare somewhat friendly shoulder he has found in you and Zeke may be putting the day off when he does start thinking about suicide. It's hard to see what you do for someone when you're dealing with what's going on in his head and in most cases probably won't ever know. You can tell when you got the bleeding under control for an accident victim. You get validation in many cases dealing with the physical.

  • Anonymous

    I'd say that at some point this guy is going to start finding the situation is more that he can handle even "well" as he is now and might turn to suicide. The rare somewhat friendly shoulder he has found in you and Zeke may be putting the day off when he does start thinking about suicide.

    It's hard to see what you do for someone when you're dealing with what's going on in his head and in most cases probably won't ever know. You can tell when you got the bleeding under control for an accident victim. You get validation in many cases dealing with the physical.

  • Cybrludite

    "They warehouse them and dope them with Haldol and Thorazine until their reimbursement capitates, and then suddenly declare that they've made significant progress and are ready to be released again into the world…"That's exactly how a private psych hospital on the North Shore "treated" a close relative of mine in the late '80s. The issues she came out of that $#!+hole with made the ones she went in with pale by comparison. It's probably a good thing for me and my permanent record that the quack who ran the place has already passed to his final reward, because I was a bit miffed once I realized just how much of my relative's current issues stem from having been in that place. (And by a bit miffed, I of course mean that I was looking for a hobby knife, a dremel tool, fishhooks, safety pins, and my soldering iron…)

  • Cybrludite

    "They warehouse them and dope them with Haldol and Thorazine until their reimbursement capitates, and then suddenly declare that they've made significant progress and are ready to be released again into the world…"

    That's exactly how a private psych hospital on the North Shore "treated" a close relative of mine in the late '80s. The issues she came out of that $#!+hole with made the ones she went in with pale by comparison. It's probably a good thing for me and my permanent record that the quack who ran the place has already passed to his final reward, because I was a bit miffed once I realized just how much of my relative's current issues stem from having been in that place. (And by a bit miffed, I of course mean that I was looking for a hobby knife, a dremel tool, fishhooks, safety pins, and my soldering iron…)

  • grandmamargie

    So sad, AD. I'm speechless.

  • grandmamargie

    So sad, AD. I'm speechless.

  • Theresa

    I am relatively new to your site, and must say that was a touching post. As a SW turned SAHM, I have seen the same desperation and it really breaks my heart that they system is broke.

  • Theresa

    I am relatively new to your site, and must say that was a touching post. As a SW turned SAHM, I have seen the same desperation and it really breaks my heart that they system is broke.

  • Anonymous

    AD, thank you for approaching this man with dignity even though you seemed to be battling within yourself. I was the one to deal with a family member in this same type of situation and it tore me apart. You are a treasure to those you assist. Thank you, Mel

  • Anonymous

    AD, thank you for approaching this man with dignity even though you seemed to be battling within yourself. I was the one to deal with a family member in this same type of situation and it tore me apart. You are a treasure to those you assist. Thank you, Mel

  • HeroHog

    Its too damned early in the morning for me to be crying…

  • HeroHog

    Its too damned early in the morning for me to be crying…

  • ArkieRN

    Heartbreaking. All the more so because there doesn't seem to be any solution. In these tough economic times the help is likely to become even harder to come by and many more people will end up by the wayside.

  • ArkieRN

    Heartbreaking. All the more so because there doesn't seem to be any solution. In these tough economic times the help is likely to become even harder to come by and many more people will end up by the wayside.

  • Amanda

    You rock, AD. You keep going even when you'd rather not… and you make a difference.Bless you for that.

  • Amanda

    You rock, AD. You keep going even when you'd rather not… and you make a difference.

    Bless you for that.

  • Roanoke Cop

    The psych system is truly lacking in resources for the demand that exists for it. I've spent many, many, shifts with psychs in the hospital,who are simply turned loose to return again next week. It's a sad state of affairs.

  • Roanoke Cop

    The psych system is truly lacking in resources for the demand that exists for it. I've spent many, many, shifts with psychs in the hospital,who are simply turned loose to return again next week. It's a sad state of affairs.

  • Linda

    ADThank you for your compassion for those that you treat. I realize it can be very hard to not show how you feel, I don't think I could.

  • Linda

    AD

    Thank you for your compassion for those that you treat. I realize it can be very hard to not show how you feel, I don't think I could.

  • Crucis

    My first degree was in Clinical Psychology. During the senior years, a clinical class was working in a near-by state hospital as a psychiatric orderly.It was horrible.I still remember one woman who appeared to be in her late 50's but was actually in her early 30's. She would show up at the hospital steps every Tues and Thursday and sit there crying. She wouldn't commit herself and no judge would do so without the recommendation from a doctor. She wouldn't go to them either.We'd bring her in, feed her breakfast and let her sleep a while on the lounge couch. She'd stay until mid-afternoon and then leave. She could have stayed if she would initiate the process. But, she wouldn't and because of that, we couldn't. She had no known relatives either as far as we could determine. The whole episode soured me on being a clinical psychologist—my goal at the time. I never completed my Master's and ended up as an engineer instead.Strange how events can change your life's path.That was in 1968. I still remember her.

  • Crucis

    My first degree was in Clinical Psychology. During the senior years, a clinical class was working in a near-by state hospital as a psychiatric orderly.

    It was horrible.

    I still remember one woman who appeared to be in her late 50's but was actually in her early 30's. She would show up at the hospital steps every Tues and Thursday and sit there crying. She wouldn't commit herself and no judge would do so without the recommendation from a doctor. She wouldn't go to them either.

    We'd bring her in, feed her breakfast and let her sleep a while on the lounge couch. She'd stay until mid-afternoon and then leave. She could have stayed if she would initiate the process. But, she wouldn't and because of that, we couldn't. She had no known relatives either as far as we could determine. The whole episode soured me on being a clinical psychologist—my goal at the time. I never completed my Master's and ended up as an engineer instead.

    Strange how events can change your life's path.

    That was in 1968. I still remember her.

  • Fordo

    Wow. Thanks, AD. We read the papers. We watch the news. We know intellectually the plight of the mentally ill in our country. We hear about the endless cycle and how people are discharged from facilities when they can't care for themselves. In this single post, though, you put us there. We saw the helplessness, fear, and sadness. We felt the anger. We smelled the fetid stench in the room.Wow. Nice post, AD.

  • Fordo

    Wow. Thanks, AD.

    We read the papers. We watch the news. We know intellectually the plight of the mentally ill in our country. We hear about the endless cycle and how people are discharged from facilities when they can't care for themselves.

    In this single post, though, you put us there. We saw the helplessness, fear, and sadness. We felt the anger. We smelled the fetid stench in the room.

    Wow. Nice post, AD.

  • Farm.Dad

    BTDT from the LE perspective, as well as trying desperately from both LE and non LE sides to get folk including family members needed help to no avail . About 3 years ago i lost a family member who was as near as i had to a brother to mental illness , the thing i resent most is not being able to help until he almost killed someone else . There was a gun fight where he shot a fella with a sawed off 12 ga , but thankfully at too long a range and too small a shot load . I regret and resent that no one concerned could get him the help he needed , but am thankful that he did not take anyone else with him . No i dont have so much as a suggestion on how to " fix " things , rather a sad acceptance of the way things are .Be careful AD , one day his demons may well erupt and it would sadden all of us if you were the one to take the brunt of that because you have somewhat of a " trust " built up .

  • Farm.Dad

    BTDT from the LE perspective, as well as trying desperately from both LE and non LE sides to get folk including family members needed help to no avail . About 3 years ago i lost a family member who was as near as i had to a brother to mental illness , the thing i resent most is not being able to help until he almost killed someone else . There was a gun fight where he shot a fella with a sawed off 12 ga , but thankfully at too long a range and too small a shot load . I regret and resent that no one concerned could get him the help he needed , but am thankful that he did not take anyone else with him . No i dont have so much as a suggestion on how to " fix " things , rather a sad acceptance of the way things are .
    Be careful AD , one day his demons may well erupt and it would sadden all of us if you were the one to take the brunt of that because you have somewhat of a " trust " built up .

  • fuzzys dad

    Thank God for your wisdom and help.

  • fuzzys dad

    Thank God for your wisdom and help.

  • 40lizard

    Thank you for caring so much AD!It's gut wrenching to say the least to know that people need help but that they have to commit a horrible act before anyone or anything can then intervene and give them the help they so desparately needed!It's a sad state of affairs that this world has arrived at to say the least!

  • 40lizard

    Thank you for caring so much AD!

    It's gut wrenching to say the least to know that people need help but that they have to commit a horrible act before anyone or anything can then intervene and give them the help they so desparately needed!

    It's a sad state of affairs that this world has arrived at to say the least!

  • Aunt Becky

    You don't know me, I don't know you, but you're an amazing soul. Thank you.

  • Aunt Becky

    You don't know me, I don't know you, but you're an amazing soul. Thank you.

  • Rogue Medic

    This is another part of the problem with EMS. We are expected to just transport patients like this. Since there is no protocol, the belief is that there is nothing that we can do. Just talking with a person can be important, but how many of us will take the time to listen to the problems of others. In stead of listening, we are just looking for the next place in the conversation where we can start talking. It is good of you to actually take that time. At least the Lortab pusher (above) is much more literate than gjerry3. Or did you delete the spam?

  • Rogue Medic

    This is another part of the problem with EMS. We are expected to just transport patients like this. Since there is no protocol, the belief is that there is nothing that we can do.

    Just talking with a person can be important, but how many of us will take the time to listen to the problems of others. In stead of listening, we are just looking for the next place in the conversation where we can start talking.

    It is good of you to actually take that time.

    At least the Lortab pusher (above) is much more literate than gjerry3. Or did you delete the spam?

  • Bob

    Lovely piece of writing, AD.

  • Bob

    Lovely piece of writing, AD.

  • Mark

    What really fucking hurts is that you care. If you didn't want to help this poor bastard, you wouldn't have written the post. You're as powerless, in a way, as he is.You take care, AD. Don't let their hopelessness in a f8cked up situation become yours. Big love, big guy.

  • Mark

    What really fucking hurts is that you care. If you didn't want to help this poor bastard, you wouldn't have written the post. You're as powerless, in a way, as he is.

    You take care, AD. Don't let their hopelessness in a f8cked up situation become yours.

    Big love, big guy.

  • Sibyl

    AD, while it may not show, you are helping that man by giving him some measure of trustworthy human contact. We go crazy when we feel isolated and unable to connect with others.I am one of the patients the ER nurses look at with disgust. How does it happen? It builds up — the fear, the loneliness, the desperation, the pain — and I act out. Without others to talk to, there is no other outlet. Should anyone see the results, like the nasty bruises from when I pounded my hand with a hammer to let out the rage, they immediately say "she needs help".Well, what is "help"? How does one find it? At 10pm, one does not call a primary care physician to ask for a referral. You can't cold-call a psychiatrist or show up on the doorstep of a mental hospital. You're taken to the ER by some well-meaning person who feels proactive about getting you "help". You go because you're drained and somebody is leading you. You hope against all hope that this time somebody will be kind instead of treating you like refuse clogging up the pipes. Every time a nurse or doctor treats me poorly, I pull a little farther away from humanity and get sicker. If you can't trust a doctor or a nurse or a police officer or an ambulance driver to be nice to you, who *can* you trust? Nobody. Might as well be dead. Back to square one.I have never once called an ambulance, mind you. When I was doubled over with pain from my appendix, I still walked into the Emergency Room on my own two feet.This was a great post you wrote. I just wanted to give you some perspective on the other side.

  • Sibyl

    AD, while it may not show, you are helping that man by giving him some measure of trustworthy human contact. We go crazy when we feel isolated and unable to connect with others.

    I am one of the patients the ER nurses look at with disgust. How does it happen? It builds up — the fear, the loneliness, the desperation, the pain — and I act out. Without others to talk to, there is no other outlet. Should anyone see the results, like the nasty bruises from when I pounded my hand with a hammer to let out the rage, they immediately say "she needs help".

    Well, what is "help"? How does one find it? At 10pm, one does not call a primary care physician to ask for a referral. You can't cold-call a psychiatrist or show up on the doorstep of a mental hospital. You're taken to the ER by some well-meaning person who feels proactive about getting you "help". You go because you're drained and somebody is leading you. You hope against all hope that this time somebody will be kind instead of treating you like refuse clogging up the pipes.

    Every time a nurse or doctor treats me poorly, I pull a little farther away from humanity and get sicker. If you can't trust a doctor or a nurse or a police officer or an ambulance driver to be nice to you, who *can* you trust? Nobody. Might as well be dead. Back to square one.

    I have never once called an ambulance, mind you. When I was doubled over with pain from my appendix, I still walked into the Emergency Room on my own two feet.

    This was a great post you wrote. I just wanted to give you some perspective on the other side.

  • jimbob86

    AD, this guy does not need to be institutionalized. He needs some human contact- a social network. He needs a purpose. He might try a Church…… or better yet, a Church should try to reach out to him.

    Say what you will about organized religion, it IS a social network and a safety net…..

    I will note that since they took God out of public schools (and pretty much out of the public square), the prisons are full and a good portion of the population is dependent upon behavior modification/pain meds…..

    …the meds don't cure them. It just warehouses them in society, as surely as the nuthouses of yeasteryear did (just out of sight).

  • jimbob86

    AD, this guy does not need to be institutionalized. He needs some human contact- a social network. He needs a purpose. He might try a Church…… or better yet, a Church should try to reach out to him.Say what you will about organized religion, it IS a social network and a safety net…..I will note that since they took God out of public schools (and pretty much out of the public square), the prisons are full and a good portion of the population is dependent upon behavior modification/pain meds….. …the meds don't cure them. It just warehouses them in society, as surely as the nuthouses of yeasteryear did (just out of sight).

  • Happymom4 aka Hope Anne

    We had a homeless, mentally ill guy that we befriend over a period of time about 5 years ago. He's now doing better, and is still our friend. We were cautious until we built up enough trust mutually, but we are so glad he entered our lives! No, we don't have a typical friendship like you might think of it, but he enjoys Christmas dinner and other times with our family, and he's a great guy who has been dealt a lot of bad blows. If every one of us would look for "the least of these" to reach out to and befriend . . . maybe sad stories like this wouldn't have to be so common. Thank you for sharing, AD.

  • Happymom4 aka Hope Anne

    We had a homeless, mentally ill guy that we befriend over a period of time about 5 years ago. He's now doing better, and is still our friend. We were cautious until we built up enough trust mutually, but we are so glad he entered our lives! No, we don't have a typical friendship like you might think of it, but he enjoys Christmas dinner and other times with our family, and he's a great guy who has been dealt a lot of bad blows. If every one of us would look for "the least of these" to reach out to and befriend . . . maybe sad stories like this wouldn't have to be so common. Thank you for sharing, AD.

  • peedee

    Wow how sad, for both of you. Great post that brought a tear to my eye. I love what "Happymom4 aka Hope Anne" and her family have done. Foster care for adults if you will. If every able family or person in this country would help just one person that needed it. Imagine the possibilities.

  • peedee

    Wow how sad, for both of you. Great post that brought a tear to my eye.

    I love what "Happymom4 aka Hope Anne" and her family have done. Foster care for adults if you will. If every able family or person in this country would help just one person that needed it. Imagine the possibilities.


Vote for me! Click Here

Polarized sunglasses, Flashlights, and Hiking boots.